Reading & Writing · 모듈 2 · 문항 14
Over the past decade, many public libraries have stopped charging fines for overdue books, and most of those libraries reported increases in borrowing afterward. A sociologist claims that the increase occurred mainly because the policy brought back former patrons: people who had stopped using the library after building up unpaid fines, she argues, returned once those fines were forgiven and no new ones could accumulate. Critics of the policy had predicted that patrons would keep books longer without fines, leaving shelves emptier, but the libraries reported no such problem. To evaluate the sociologist's claim, researchers examined borrowing records from several libraries before and after fines were eliminated.
Which finding from the researchers' examination, if true, would most directly weaken the sociologist's claim?
- A. At the libraries studied, total borrowing rose by an average of about 10 percent during the first year after fines were eliminated.
- B. In surveys, many patrons who had unpaid fines said they had avoided the library because they were embarrassed to owe money.
- C. Libraries in the same region that continued to charge overdue fines saw their total borrowing remain roughly level over the same ten-year period.
- D. Nearly all of the increase in borrowing came from people who had never held a library card before and so had no record of unpaid fines.