Text 1
In a 2009 study, a team of psychologists compared monolingual and bilingual eight-year-olds on tasks that required switching rapidly between rules—sorting cards by color, then by shape, for example. The bilingual children completed the switches faster and made fewer errors. Because bilingual speakers must constantly manage two languages, selecting one while suppressing the other, the researchers concluded that this daily practice strengthens the mental control processes that the tasks measure. The advantage, they noted, appeared on every version of the task.
Text 2
Psychologist Lena Hartmann notes that many early studies of bilingual children relied on small groups that differed in more than language. In several cases, the bilingual children came from families with higher incomes and more years of parental schooling—factors that are independently linked to performance on attention tasks. When Hartmann’s team tested more than 1,000 children and statistically accounted for such factors, the bilingual and monolingual groups performed almost identically. Such factors, she argues, must be ruled out before any mental benefit is credited to language itself.