Reading & Writing · 모듈 2 · 문항 14
A historian argues that a severe, decade-long drought caused the abandonment of a medieval farming settlement in a highland valley around 1350. As her main evidence, she cites the unusually narrow growth rings in timbers taken from the settlement's buildings, rings that tree-ring specialists have dated to the years 1340 through 1350. Because trees in the region usually grow less in dry years, the historian reasons that the narrow rings record a long period of low rainfall, one that would have made it impossible for the settlement's residents to grow enough grain to survive.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the historian's argument?
- A. Timbers from a settlement in a neighboring valley also show narrow rings for the years 1340 through 1350.
- B. Pollen in lake sediments near the settlement shows that grain cultivation there began declining around 1345.
- C. The settlement's timbers came from a shaded ravine where trees grow slowly whatever the rainfall, and other trees in the valley show normal rings for 1340–1350.
- D. Records show that another settlement in the same valley was also abandoned around 1350.