In the cold, clear lakes of a mountain range in western Canada, a small freshwater snail shows striking variation in shell thickness: in some lakes its shells are nearly twice as thick as in others. Two explanations have been proposed. The first holds that thickness is a response to predators. Crayfish, which crush snails in their claws, release chemical cues into the water, and many snail species are known to alter their growth when they detect such cues, building heavier shells that resist crushing. The second explanation emphasizes chemistry rather than predators. Snails build their shells from calcium carbonate, and lakes vary widely in how much dissolved calcium they contain; where calcium is plentiful, snails may simply be able to afford thicker shells. Distinguishing between these explanations is difficult because the two factors tend to occur together. Crayfish also need calcium to harden their own outer skeletons, so they are most common in calcium-rich lakes, and a survey that merely compares lakes with and without crayfish cannot reveal which factor is responsible for any difference in shells. Laboratory studies of related snail species have offered some support for each explanation, so only field data gathered from the lakes themselves could settle the question. After sampling snails from forty lakes and measuring both crayfish abundance and dissolved calcium in each one, a team of ecologists concluded that predator cues, not calcium availability, are the main driver of the variation in shell thickness.