In many towns, residents can now borrow not only books but also drills, sewing machines, camping tents, and cake pans from a “library of things.” Supporters say these collections save money and reduce waste, since a household that needs a ladder twice a year does not have to buy one. To learn how such libraries are actually used, a team of sociologists studied lending records from four tool libraries in the United States over a period of three years.
The researchers expected that the most frequent borrowers would be people with low incomes, who might be least able to afford tools of their own. Instead, the records told a more complicated story. Income made only a small difference in how often people borrowed. The strongest predictor was housing: residents of apartments borrowed nearly twice as often as residents of houses, regardless of income. Interviews suggested a simple reason. Many apartment dwellers said they could easily afford a power drill but had nowhere to store one.
The team also noticed a change over time. In the first year, most loans were for practical tools. By the third year, a growing share of loans were for items tied to hobbies, such as bread-making equipment and telescopes, which borrowers described as a way to try an activity before deciding whether to invest in it.