Reading & Writing · Module 2 · Question 14
When caterpillars chew on a tomato plant, the plant produces chemicals that make its leaves harder to digest. Producing these chemicals takes energy that the plant could otherwise spend on growth, so a plant that starts its defenses early, before any insect arrives, gains protection but pays a cost if no attack ever comes. Researchers hypothesize that damaged plants also release airborne compounds that prompt nearby undamaged tomato plants to start making these defensive chemicals before they are attacked. Earlier studies seemed to support this idea, because undamaged plants growing beside damaged ones often increased their defenses. Critics noted, however, that the plants in those studies shared the same soil, and their roots were often tangled together, so the signal could have traveled underground through the roots or soil instead of through the air.
Which finding, if true, would most strongly support the researchers' hypothesis?
- A. Undamaged plants in sealed chambers that received air from damaged plants raised their defenses, but those receiving air from undamaged plants did not.
- B. Tomato plants that were damaged by caterpillars produced much larger amounts of defensive chemicals than undamaged plants produced.
- C. Undamaged plants raised their defenses when grown next to damaged plants, even though the roots of the two plants were tangled together.
- D. Caterpillars ate noticeably less of plants with high levels of defensive chemicals than of plants with low levels of these chemicals.