Reading & Writing · Module 2 · Question 14
Historical climatologists have increasingly turned to the logbooks of nineteenth-century sailing ships, which recorded weather conditions several times a day across vast stretches of ocean where few other records of any kind exist. Skeptics point out that the entries were written by thousands of different officers, many without scientific training, and that standards for describing weather differed between navies and merchant fleets. To test whether the logbooks are nonetheless reliable, a team of researchers compared entries from pairs of ships that, according to their recorded positions, sailed within a few kilometers of each other on the same day. Wind directions, which officers read from a compass, matched closely between paired ships. Wind strength, however, which officers judged by eye using descriptive phrases such as “fresh breeze” or “strong gale,” matched far less consistently, and the mismatches were largest when the two ships belonged to different fleets. These results suggest that ______
Which choice most logically completes the text?
- A. the logbooks, having been written by so many officers using so many different standards, are too inconsistent to be useful for reconstructing any feature of past ocean weather.
- B. officers without scientific training recorded wind direction less accurately than officers with such training did.
- C. the differences in how fleets described wind strength resulted mainly from differences in the compasses that the fleets used.
- D. climatologists can trust the logbooks' wind directions more than their wind strengths, especially when combining records from different fleets.