Reading & Writing · 모듈 2 · 문항 14
In the seventeenth century, the port town of Elmsby (a pseudonym used in a recent study) handled much of the wool trade along its stretch of coast, but by 1700 its shipping had nearly vanished. Many historians have blamed the arrival of a rival port, which opened twenty miles to the south in 1652 and offered merchants larger warehouses. A historian has recently argued instead that Elmsby declined chiefly because silt carried by the river gradually filled its harbor, making it too shallow for the larger cargo ships that were coming into use. In her view, competition from the rival port mattered only after silting had already made Elmsby’s harbor difficult to use, at which point merchants who had once been loyal to the town had little choice but to move their business elsewhere.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the historian’s claim?
- A. Several other ports on the same coast that suffered heavy silting in the seventeenth century also lost most of their shipping.
- B. Letters written by Elmsby merchants in the 1690s frequently complain that ships ran aground at the harbor entrance.
- C. Throughout the second half of the seventeenth century, the rival port charged merchants considerably lower fees than Elmsby did for storing wool in its warehouses.
- D. Elmsby’s shipping fell sharply in the decade after 1652, but surveys show the harbor channel did not narrow much until about 1700.